Skip to main content

Making India Work [Book Review]

On my recent visit to traditional outfit store fabindia, I spotted the book by its founder William Nanda Bissel for sale and I being me could not resist buying a copy for myself. Making India Work is an ambitious attempt to dream a new India - but may be its a little too ambitious.

Nanda Bissel talks about a complete revamp of the way India is governed - from its administrative divisions (46 Regions instead of 28 states) to the way ministries are organized and managed. It is quite easy for us to write off his ideas giving reasons like our politicians would never bring about such changes or because the bureaucracy would block all attempts for these ideas to succeed.

However, I have more fundamental differences with the proposals being made in the book (while I also concede that I like a lot of proposals made by him). Before we jump to them, let me outline a few of his proposals in brief:
  • National Division: Lots of proposals have come through for decentralization of power or in favour of smaller states, but William Nanda Bissel takes the idea to the next level proposing to create a community for every 25k  population, an area for every 100 communities and a region for every 10 areas - making about 40-50 regions in the country. 
  • Institutions: Bissel proposes to create various standards bodies for determining value of everything from fresh air, trees, power, water, waste, bandwidth etc. and exchanges for communities to trade them.
  • Government: Bissel argues for a radical change in the Government structure abolishing the upper house, leaving the Union government with only defense and foreign affairs portfolios and leaving all other departments with 'Region' governments. 
The above 3 radical changes, Bissel claims that over time will create a balance as cities start paying for the natural resources they use and rural communities start getting the benefit of the same resources which they own.This will give resources to rural communities to develop basic amenities like paved streets and drinking water taps while on the other hand motivate urban communities to consume less, develop efficient means - for example substitute public transport for personal vehicles.

The above changes are quite apt for the new 21st century world where environment and technology are together paving way for new social structure and new set of values completely distinct than those of the industrial world. Some of them - such as valuation of natural assets - are applicable not just to developing economies like India but even developed ones in Western Europe and the US.

Bissel himself explains, developed economies have developed a wasteful lifestyle. An example was suburbs in the US which are made possible by roads which connect them to the main city - but the residents of the suburbs do not directly pay for construction or maintenance of these roads which is paid for by the government. The suburban spread is wasteful because due to low density sprawl, public transport is not feasible, so people use private cars - often gas guzzler SUVs; amenities such as water, sewage and mail transport are inefficient because low density means higher costs per capita.

All the above makes a lot of sense and needs to be implemented; however for someone of the experience of Bissel - its a little naive to propose a top-down change in fundamental systems when he himself claims elsewhere in the book that a bottom-up approach is needed to change the system.

Secondly, some of the propositions are far too simplistic - for example it does sound fair in principle that only defense and foreign affairs stays with the central government. But think about it - if we had only a regulator for telecom and no ministry - would it have been possible to catalyze the explosive growth of the telecommunications sector; or think of certain national assets like rivers and forests / national parks - if we do not have central ministries to act as mediators - there would be many more feuds like the Krishna Water dispute in the country.

Under Bissel's system, we would end up having as many 'regulators' or 'tribunals' for all such matters. And so, how different would Bissel's system would end up instead of the current system. Does replacing ministries with regulators make any difference?

Finally, the chapter on transition (Ch 8) falls completely short of one'e expectations - one starts expecting what public support, intermediate reforms needed to reach to the end state - may be a gradual division of states to reach the number of 46 regions proposed in the book, or subsequent decentralization of power to empower municipalities, creation of more panchayats and finally merging the two elementary governance structures to create a common structure - community. However, the transition starts with a call for constitutional amendment without talking about how to build a consensus for adoption of the altered system in the country.

Overall, the ideas proposed in the book are quite useful but they probably would have been more palatable and acceptable to the real change makers - bureaucrats and politicians - had they been presented in a form similar to Nandan Nilekani's Imagining India. In its current state, the book runs a risk of being written off as a pipe dream.

And I say this not just from a vicarious or academic experience of reading books on development - but from personal experience of working with government offices and public sector enterprises. I will elaborate in the next post.

[Read Part II here]


    1. Would you like to review my book (IndiaWasOne)? If so, email me at

    2. India Was One for School Libraries

      Cypress, California – January 1, 2013 - India Was One was submitted to be considered for inclusion in ALL the School Libraries across America (over 26,000). There were 15,000 books submitted, and after passing through all the rounds, India Was One entered the final round.
      “AABV is so proud of how far your book got in the process,” said a spokesperson from American Authors Book Vending (who submitted the book).

      India Was One is a work of fiction interwoven with real events, thus labeled a realistic-fiction. Each chapter of the book begins with an artwork, giving us vignettes of the characters’ lives in Mumbai and later in the US.

      India Was One is written by an anonymous author who calls himself ‘an Indian’. It is available for sale on Flipkart, Indiaplaza, Pothi, and many more online stores in India. The best way to see where it is available is to visit the book’s website,

      About the Author

      The author was born and raised in Mumbai, India. He came to the US in 1989 and lived in New York. He currently resides in Los Angeles with his wife and two children.
      For more information about INDIA WAS ONE, please visit WWW.INDIAWASONE.COM or contact the author at


    Post a Comment

    Popular posts from this blog

    How will travel industry transform post-Covid

    Unlike philosophers, journalists and teenagers, the world of entrepreneurship does not permit the luxury of gazing into a crystal ball to predict the future. An entrepreneur’s world is instead made of MVPs (Minimum Viable Product), A/B Tests, launching products, features or services and gauging / measuring their reception in the market to arrive at verifiable truths which can drive the business forward. Which is why I have never written about my musings or hypothesis about travel industry – we usually either seek customer feedback or launch an MVPised version and gather market feedback. However, with Covid-19 travel bans across the globe, the industry is currently stuck – while a lot of industry reports and journalistic conjectures are out, there’s no definitive answer to the way forward. Besides there is no way to test your hypothesis since even the traveller does not know what they will do when skies open. So, I decided to don my blogger hat and take the luxury of crystal gazing

    A Guide to Privacy on Social Media [apps]

    The recent announcement by WhatsApp to update its privacy terms - and 'accept or leave the app' stance - led to an exodus of users from Whastapp to competing, privacy-conscious apps such as Telegram or Signal. A week after the exodus began, Whatsapp clarified its stance - and WhatsApp's CEO went about providing a long Twitter clarification . And then, many returned, many who considered moving stayed put on Whatsapp. This post is meant for those who are still sitting on the fence - it clarifies questions like: What is this all about? What do I do? Is Whatsapp safe? I've heard Telegram is Russian - so how is it safer than Whatsapp? I can't move because my business contacts are on Whastapp - how do I secure myself? PS: I've modeled this post based on several conversations I've had with friends and family on this subject, dealing with the chain of questions they ask, then objections they raise, then clarifications they seek - and finally the change resistance

    Ekla Chalo re

    Watched "Bose- The forgotten Hero" on Saturday. Gem of a movie and probably the best of Shyam Benegal. Subhash Chandra Bose has always been an inspiring character in the history for the youth. This post however is not about the movie, its about the lead song 'Tanha Rahee' which is based on the poem 'Ekla Chalo Re' by Gurudev Rabindranath Tagore. I had pasted the English translation of this poem on my blog earlier. However, yesterday I found the original bengali text of the poem and found that the meaning in the above translation was not exact. So I have endeavourer (with the help of Shubham ) to re-translate it into English and Hindi by myself. Here is the output of my work: Bengali Jodi Tor Dak Soone Keu Na Asse Tobe Ekla Chalo re Ekla Chalo Ekla Chalo Ekla Chalore Jodi Keu Katha Na Kai Ore Ore O Abhaga Jodi Sabai Thake Mukh Firae Sabai Kare Bhay Tabe Paran Khule O Tui Mukh Fute Tor Maner Kath