Why is the UK burning again?

Photo courtesy Stringer/Reuters

It has been another weekend of rioting, larceny and arson in the UK, this time in Rotherham and Tamworth - the worst civil unrest since the 2011 riots. As I reflect on my previous analysis from 2011, it is evident that many of the underlying issues that fueled those riots remain unresolved today. In my 2011 blog post, I explored the complex socio-economic factors that contributed to the riots, including disenfranchisement, lack of opportunities, and systemic inequalities. Fast forward to 2024, and we are witnessing a resurgence of unrest, this time triggered by anti-immigrant sentiments and actions against asylum seekers [1] [2]. 

While the immediate causes and triggers of the current riots may differ - fueled by far-right ideologies and a backlash against immigration - the underlying issues of inequality, lack of social cohesion, and economic disenfranchisement persist. The current climate reflects a society grappling with similar frustrations that were evident in 2011.

The recurring theme of social unrest highlights a critical failure in addressing the root causes of discontent. A significant aspect of this is the inadequacy of vocational education and training systems in the UK. Many young people feel left behind, lacking the skills necessary to thrive in a rapidly changing job market. This disillusionment can lead to feelings of hopelessness and anger, often manifesting in violent protests. 

As an aside, it is quite unnerving to hear the British Prime Minister Keir Starmer resort to comparisons of rioters with Nazi and labeling them as merely right-wing rioters. At least to me, the visuals (one of which is shown above), did not hint any Nazi symbols. On the contrary, the symbol in the image is the anarchist "A" symbol - a political philosophy that advocates for a stateless society, often characterized by opposition to hierarchical structures and authoritarianism. In contrast, the Nazi ideology is associated with authoritarian, supremacist, and racist beliefs, which are fundamentally opposed to the principles of anarchism.

To further substantiate this claim, I tried to find research papers on this subject that delve into the connection between education failures and social unrest. Research [3] showcases that there is a relationship between horizontal inequality and instability in a number of ways. This research suggests that it is not ethnic fractionalization per se that matters but whether ethnicity is politically salient and horizontal inequality could be one of the factors that increase the salience of ethnicity. And there is a academic evidence [4] [5] how a good education system can help reduce uncivil protests, rather prompt people to engage in structured and constructive ‘civic co-operation’.

By revisiting these themes, we can better understand the cyclical nature of unrest in the UK. The current riots serve as a stark reminder that without addressing the systemic issues at play, including the failures of vocational education, we may continue to see similar patterns of civil disorder in the future.

As we reflect on the past and present, it is crucial to engage in meaningful dialogue about how to address these persistent issues. The lessons from 2011 should not be forgotten; instead, they should inform the approach to creating a more inclusive and equitable society. Only then can we hope to break the cycle of unrest and build a future where all individuals have the opportunity to thrive.

.